INQUIRE ABOUT ADVERTISING ON THE ADD BLOG

Trouble with Comics, Daily Breakdowns 088 - 1s for the Team

Daily Breakdowns 088 - 1s for the Team

Quick looks at a few first issues of team books from this week and last.

Astonishing X-Men: Xenogenesis #1

Writer - Warren Ellis. Artist - Kaare Andrews. Marvel Comics.

There are a couple nice things going on in this miniseries. First, Ellis does a good job grounding the X-Men in our heartbreaking world, in this case dropping some depressing African recent history. At the same time, he brings the strange with the X-Men’s mission, which is to investigate a run of supposed mutant births in a small, fictional African country. The reports of some of the weird births set up that Andrews may have some cool things to draw next issue.

Where the book doesn’t work as well is, well, the choice of Andrews. Actually, put me down as undecided for now. Let’s just say that if Ellis is going to make any kind of statement on Africa, or poverty, or children with special needs or any serious issue that could spring up, then Andrews’ exaggerated, kinky style will really clash and undermine the story. If, now that the facts have been relayed, we’re heading into fairly typical superhero terrain, then sure, I’m down for all the innuendos about Scott being turned on by Emma’s fake British accent, Emma smashing her breasts on the table for Wolverine’s benefit, and whatever else Ellis and Andrews cook up. It’s a miniseries, go nuts.

Avengers (v4) #1

Writer - Brian Michael Bendis. Pencils - John Romita, Jr. Inks - Klaus Janson. Marvel Comics.

This relaunch succeeded and disappointed in ways I wasn’t expecting. Bendis is more admired for his dialogue than plotting, but I thought this was pretty flat. Aside from some characters like Hawkeye developing that Bendis stammer, no one is written out of character, per se, but there aren’t any juicy exchanges, either. Steve Rogers has decided that Tony Stark/Iron Man needs to be an Avenger again, and so he’s burying the hatchet, and leaving the day-to-day to Maria Hill. Two people he’s had major issues with in the recent past. Sure, it says something about Rogers’ character, but it also reduces the dramatic opportunities here. In fact, the issue really reeks of wanting to forget about the last few years and just get onto being a big superteam book again, with everyone working together. A change in tone and an attempt at a fresh start for new or returning readers are both sensible, but it still feels abrupt. Hawkeye is Hawkeye again, casting aside the Ronin guise as the gimmick it was with a self-conscious exchange with Spider-Man about the sudden shift. Speaking of Spider-Man, as Bendis has shown an affinity for writing him before, I confess I just don’t get why he chooses to just make him the comic relief here, with a really annoying compulsion to make a “humorous” comment every minute. I get that he’s not as powerful as some of the heroes here (though more powerful than Hawkeye, Rogers or Spider-Woman), but shouldn’t he instead be played as the never-give-up guy? Especially with Rogers stepping aside to run the Secret Avengers, Spidey should be the heart of this team. 

I really don’t tire of the combination of Romita, Jr. and Janson. Always good.

Legion of Super-Heroes (v6) #1

Writer - Paul Levitz. Penciler - Yildiray Cinar. Inker - Wayne Faucher. DC Comics.

The first LOSH story I read was Levitz and Giffen’s “Great Darkness Saga,” and I liked it, but over the years I’ve only been a sporadic reader and never lasted all that long. It’s kind of interesting after a big chunk of my comics-reading life to be considering Levitz as just another freelance writer rather than as the frustrating guy running DC Comics. 

While Cinar is serviceable, I really think this book needs someone more exciting and distinctive for it to have a chance, especially when Levitz’ writing is decidedly old school. That’s not such a bad thing, as he packs a lot of story in this double-sized issue, with nary a full-page spread, and he makes decent use of declasse’ thought balloons as well as the convenient little floating boxes that identify the various Legionnaires by codename, real name, home planet and superpower(s). At the same time, nobody stands out here but Saturn Girl, who was just settling in for a good tantrum over her jerk husband when her planet is attacked and twin sons kidnapped. You’d be a sympathetic character if either of these things happened to you. I can’t say there’s a whole lot to hook me here, but I may give it another issue or two.

—Christopher Allen

blog comments powered by Disqus